It’s a rainy morning in Socal – a pleasant aberration. Maybe not so unusual if the predictions about El Niño are true. But it’s a good morning for some reading and writing.
The thing most on my mind is that I think we’ve hit peak Musk, and we’re going to have to deal with that. He’s given half a billion dollars to Republican candidates the last few months. $500M…just for midterm elections. Thanks to SCOTUS and Citizens United, it’s all mostly legal. That needs to change.
But that’s not the biggest problem. The real issue is that we’ve allowed one person, an unstable racist, to control the high ground for warfare, for all nations. Musk controls SpaceX, now the only viable way to get payloads launched into orbit reliably. Our military depends on SpaceX to launch all our orbital assets. Plus, Musk has used his own rockets to launch the dominant low Earth orbit communications system, Starlink, and its US military version, StarShield. Tens of thousands of satellites are now used worldwide, including to guide drones in the Russia-Ukraine war. And in that war, Musk has turned off Starlink for Ukraine, leaving them relatively defenseless against Russian attacks. Ukraine is (was) the state of the art user of drone offense and defense, and they built that capability using Starlink for comms. And one man decided to shut them down, changing the course of a war.
It’s too much. One unstable man should not be the only way the United States can launch orbital assets. One unstable and unelected man should certainly not be able to undermine US foreign policy by crippling our ally. And it’s getting worse every day, as SpaceX’s lead in rocketry is increasing. No other country or company can do what they can.
So what do we do? There are calls to nationalize SpaceX and/or Starlink, and that wrong to me. Musk built these companies in our system, in our country, with our rules. Though it has to be said that both Starlink and SpaceX have received billions in US tax dollars via subsidies, contracts, and outright grants. So it hasn’t been pure capitalism driving their growth. US taxpayers have a stake here. But the US government seizing Musk’s companies still feels wrong, at least to me.
If we had a functional Congress and SCOTUS, I’d say we need some new guardrail legislation. Laws requiring independent control of any Starlink components used by foreign governments or for war. Laws requiring SpaceX to launch US military assets at no cost, given the subsidies they’ve received. And laws to transfer their rocketry tech to NASA (if only NASA were competent). But Congress won’t do anything intelligent and even if they did, SCOTUS would undo it.
So at the moment we’re stuck with an unstable, racist engineering genius in control of space. It sounds like a bad Bond movie. But unfortunately it’s reality.
The new Congress, hopefully Dem-controlled, has a chance to change course on this. The first thing they should do is make it clear how much of Musk’s success is built on US taxpayer money. Simultaneously, they should drop the hammer on the Ukraine situation. We CANNOT allow a single private citizen to undermine US foreign policy with the flip of a switch. Perhaps StarShield, a subset of Starlink, should be carved off and nationalized. I could live with that, though it sets a bad precedent.
Bottom line, we (US citizens) are in a bad place. One person has gained the power of life and death during warfare, control over global communications, control over orbital space. And that person is not friendly. We have a problem.






